Carbonatite Deposits: Rich in Rare Earths


Rare Earth Elements (REEs) are a group of 17 chemically similar elements with diverse applications in modern technologies. These elements play a crucial role in various industries, including electronics, renewable energy, healthcare, and defense. As the demand for REEs continues to grow, the exploration and extraction of these valuable resources have become paramount.

One of the most prominent sources of REEs is found in carbonatite deposits. Carbonatites are unique igneous rocks enriched in carbonate minerals, and they hold exceptional concentrations of rare earth elements. Carbonatite deposits are dominant in the Rare Earth Element scene, being that they are the best type of rare earth element deposit. By understanding the formation, advantages, challenges, and economic aspects of carbonatite deposits, we will gain valuable insights into their critical role in meeting the global demand for rare earth elements.

Understanding Rare Earth Elements

Rare Earth Elements (REEs) despite their name, rare earth elements are not actually rare in the Earth’s crust; however, they are often found in low concentrations, making their extraction challenging and costly. REEs are essential components in various modern technologies due to their unique properties. For instance, neodymium and praseodymium are critical for the production of high-strength permanent magnets used in wind turbines, electric vehicles, and computer hard drives. Cerium is used in catalytic converters to reduce emissions from automobiles. Lanthanum is utilized in rechargeable batteries and camera lenses. Moreover, europium, terbium, and yttrium are indispensable in the production of color displays for televisions and smartphones.

Global Demand for REEs and Their Strategic Significance

The demand for rare earth elements has skyrocketed in recent years, driven primarily by the increasing adoption of green technologies and the rapid expansion of electronics industries worldwide. The rise of renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar power, relies heavily on REEs for energy-efficient technologies.

Global Solar Power Market Size Forcast(Precedence Research)

Furthermore, the strategic significance of REEs extends to national security and defense applications. These elements are essential for manufacturing precision-guided missiles, radar systems, night vision goggles, and other advanced defense equipment.

China has historically been the dominant producer of rare earth elements, accounting for a significant portion of the global supply. However, this concentration of production raised concerns about supply chain vulnerabilities and potential geopolitical tensions. As a result, many countries have sought to diversify their sources of rare earth elements to ensure stable access to these critical materials.

Types of Rare Earth Element Deposits

Carbonatite Deposits: Definition and Characteristics

Carbonatite deposits are a specific type of igneous rock formation that differs from conventional volcanic rocks. These deposits are rich in carbonate minerals, such as calcite and dolomite, and are associated with an array of rare earth elements. The carbonatite magma that gives rise to these deposits originates from the Earth’s mantle and ascends to the surface through various geological processes.

What sets carbonatite deposits apart is their remarkable enrichment in rare earth elements. These deposits can contain significantly higher concentrations of REEs compared to other types of mineral deposits. The unique geological conditions and processes that contribute to their formation create an environment conducive to the concentration and accumulation of these valuable elements.

Other REE Deposit Types (e.g., Ion-adsorption Clays, Monazite Sands)

Besides carbonatite deposits, there are several other types of mineral deposits where rare earth elements can be found. Some of the notable ones include ion-adsorption clays and monazite sands.

Ion-adsorption clays, predominantly found in southern China, host significant amounts of light rare earth elements, particularly in the ionic form. These deposits are relatively shallow and can be extracted through cost-effective and environmentally friendly methods.

Monazite sands, on the other hand, contain high levels of thorium and uranium along with rare earth elements. They are typically found in beach and river sediments and are a potential source of both light and heavy rare earth elements.

Click Here to see a recent research report outlining the top REE projects around the world and their deposit type

Comparative Analysis of REE Yield in Different Deposit Types

When considering the extraction of rare earth elements, the choice of deposit type is crucial due to variations in concentration, accessibility, and economic feasibility. Carbonatite deposits stand out for their exceptional concentrations of REEs, making them highly attractive for mining operations.

However, other deposit types, such as ion-adsorption clays and monazite sands, have their advantages. These deposits may offer a more straightforward extraction process and may be strategically located closer to industrial centers, reducing transportation costs.

The comparative analysis of REE yield in different deposit types is essential for understanding the global supply of rare earth elements and developing sustainable strategies to meet the rising demand. In the next section, we will explore the geological processes that lead to the formation of carbonatite deposits and the factors contributing to their high enrichment in rare earth elements.

As outlined by Ore Geology Reviews’ recent report on global REE projects around the world, 86.5% of all active REE projects are Carbonatites. This shows the absolute dominance Carbonate hosted projects are when creating a producing REE project.

Global mine production of rare earth oxides (containing Y; 1985–2022) by country ( Ore Geology Reviews)

The Formation of Carbonatite Deposits

The formation of carbonatite deposits involves complex geological processes that take place deep within the Earth’s crust. These deposits originate from carbonatite magmas, which are generated by partial melting of the Earth’s mantle. The specific mechanisms behind carbonatite magma generation are still a subject of ongoing research and scientific inquiry.

One prevailing theory suggests that carbonatite magmas form through the melting of subducted oceanic crust or continental lithosphere in the mantle. As this material undergoes partial melting, it gives rise to the carbonatite melt, which eventually rises towards the Earth’s surface due to its lower density compared to the surrounding rocks.

Distribution and Occurrence of Carbonatite Deposits Worldwide

Carbonatite deposits are distributed globally, although they are relatively rare compared to other types of mineral deposits. They are found in various regions across different continents, each with its unique geological history.

Some well-known areas where carbonatite deposits have been discovered include the Mountain Pass mine in California, USA, the Bayan Obo deposit in Inner Mongolia, China, and the Songwe Hill deposit in Malawi. Each of these deposits contains abundant rare earth elements, making them essential sources for meeting global REE demand.

As well, there are still large projects that are still in the pre-production stages. Commerce Resources ($CCE) owns the Ashram Deposit in Quebec, Canada. The Ashram deposit is the largest Monazite dominate carbonatite hosted Rare Earth Element deposit in North America.

The top 30 REE projects by estimated total value (Ore Geology Reviews)

Key Factors Contributing to High REE Enrichment in Carbonatites

The formation of carbonatite deposits contributes to the exceptional enrichment of rare earth elements within them. Several key factors play a role in this high enrichment:

  1. Incompatible Element Enrichment: During the formation of carbonatite magma, certain elements, including rare earth elements, become enriched due to their incompatibility with the surrounding mantle rocks.
  2. Crystal Fractionation: As the carbonatite magma cools and solidifies, certain minerals rich in rare earth elements may crystallize and separate from the remaining melt. This process can further concentrate the REEs in the carbonatite deposit.
  3. Hydrothermal Processes: Subsequent hydrothermal activity can modify the composition of the carbonatite deposit, leading to further concentration of rare earth elements in specific zones.

Understanding these geological processes and factors contributing to the high REE enrichment in carbonatites is crucial for the successful exploration and extraction of rare earth elements. In the next section, we will explore the advantages of carbonatite deposits for rare earth elements, highlighting why they are considered the most dominant and best type of deposit for meeting the global demand for REEs.

Advantages of Carbonatite Deposits for Rare Earth Elements

Exceptional Concentrations of REEs

Carbonatite deposits stand out for their extraordinary concentrations of rare earth elements. Compared to other types of mineral deposits, carbonatites can contain significantly higher percentages of REEs, making them highly attractive for mining and extraction purposes. This characteristic ensures that a relatively smaller volume of ore needs to be processed to obtain a substantial amount of rare earth elements, which can result in cost-effective and efficient production. This can be further visualized by seeing the top 30 global REE projects and looking at the percentage of magnet material for Carbonatite projects compared to others.

Accessibility and Ease of Extraction

Another advantage of carbonatite deposits is their accessibility and relatively straightforward extraction methods. In many cases, carbonatite deposits are exposed at or near the Earth’s surface, making them easier to access than deeper or more remote deposits. This accessibility reduces the need for extensive underground mining operations, which can be costly and complex.

Furthermore, the carbonatite ore is often amenable to open-pit mining, a method that involves removing overburden to expose the ore body. This approach can streamline the extraction process and lead to faster and more efficient production.

Economic Viability and Sustainability

Given the high concentrations of rare earth elements found in carbonatite deposits, these sources offer significant economic viability for mining companies and governments alike. The abundant REE content in carbonatites contributes to a more attractive return on investment and helps secure a stable supply of these critical materials for industries and technologies dependent on them.

Moreover, the sustainable aspect of carbonatite mining stems from the relatively lower environmental impact compared to some other extraction methods. With responsible mining practices and adherence to environmental regulations, carbonatite deposits can be developed and operated in an environmentally conscious manner.

Overall, the exceptional concentrations of REEs, accessibility, ease of extraction, economic viability, and potential for sustainability make carbonatite deposits the best and most dominant source for rare earth elements. In the subsequent section, we will explore the challenges and opportunities associated with carbonatite-based rare earth element mining and their role in meeting global demand. This can be further understood by taking a look at the percentage of active REE mines globally that are carbonatites (86%) compared to other deposit types.


Challenges and Opportunities

Geopolitical Considerations in the Supply of REEs

The global supply of rare earth elements has long been influenced by geopolitical factors. Historically, China has been the dominant producer of REEs, controlling a significant portion of the market. This concentration of supply raised concerns among other countries about potential supply disruptions and trade restrictions.

However, the emergence of carbonatite deposits as a dominant source of rare earth elements presents an opportunity for diversifying the supply chain and reducing dependency on a single source. By developing and utilizing carbonatite deposits in other regions, countries can mitigate geopolitical risks and enhance the stability of rare earth element supply on a global scale. Such as Commerce Resources,  listed as the 7th most valuable Rare Earth Element Project globally despite it not being in production yet.  Furthermore, ranked as the 4th most valuable Carbonanite project globally, with Monazite as the mineralization type– the same as the most valuable REE project globally.

Environmental Impact and Mitigation Strategies

Like any mining operation, the extraction of rare earth elements from carbonatite deposits comes with environmental challenges. Open-pit mining and ore processing can lead to habitat disruption, water pollution, and energy consumption. Additionally, the extraction of REEs requires the use of chemicals and generates waste materials.

Addressing these environmental concerns requires the implementation of rigorous mitigation strategies. Sustainable mining practices, reclamation plans, and environmentally responsible waste management can help minimize the impact of carbonatite mining on local ecosystems and communities.

Future Prospects and Research Areas

Carbonatite deposits offer a promising avenue for securing rare earth elements, but there are still areas of research and development to explore. The scientific community and the mining industry are continually seeking more efficient and environmentally friendly methods for extracting REEs from carbonatites.

Advancements in mineral processing technologies, as well as the development of novel extraction techniques, can further improve the economic viability and sustainability of carbonatite-based rare earth element mining. Additionally, ongoing research into the geology of carbonatite formation and the factors influencing REE enrichment can enhance our understanding of these unique deposits.

Sustainable Mining Practices in Carbonatite Deposits

Mining rare earth elements from carbonatite deposits requires a commitment to responsible and sustainable practices to minimize environmental impacts and ensure the well-being of local communities. To achieve this, mining companies adopt various strategies to mitigate negative effects and promote long-term sustainability.

  1. Environmental Impact Assessment: Conducting comprehensive environmental impact assessments is a crucial first step in understanding potential ecological consequences. These assessments help identify sensitive habitats, potential water quality issues, and other environmental concerns, enabling better planning and mitigation.
  2. Reclamation and Rehabilitation: Proper land reclamation and rehabilitation are vital to restore the disturbed areas to their original or improved ecological state after mining activities have ceased. By replanting vegetation, stabilizing slopes, and restoring natural habitats, mining companies can mitigate the long-term effects of their operations.
  3. Water Management: Carbonatite mining may involve water-intensive processes, such as ore processing and dust control. Adopting efficient water management practices, including recycling and minimizing water usage, can reduce the impact on local water resources.

Recycling and Reusing REEs to Reduce Reliance on Mining

Promoting the recycling and reusing of rare earth elements is another important aspect of achieving sustainability in the rare earth element industry. Recycling electronic waste, such as discarded smartphones and laptops, can recover valuable REEs and reduce the need for virgin materials from mining.

Governments and industries are increasingly recognizing the importance of recycling and implementing policies and initiatives to encourage responsible e-waste recycling. By embracing circular economy principles, we can minimize the environmental impact of rare earth element production and enhance resource efficiency.

Sustainable mining practices and the promotion of recycling efforts in the rare earth element sector are crucial steps in ensuring a more sustainable and responsible supply chain. By integrating these practices, the carbonatite deposits, with their rich rare earth element content, can be harnessed as a valuable resource while minimizing environmental harm and supporting the transition toward a greener and more sustainable future.

Carbonatite Deposits vs. Other REE Deposits: A Comparative Economic Analysis

Cost-effectiveness and Production Economics

When comparing carbonatite deposits to other types of rare earth element deposits, cost-effectiveness and production economics are essential considerations. Carbonatite deposits are known for their exceptional concentrations of REEs, which often result in a more cost-effective extraction process. As mentioned earlier, a smaller volume of ore needs to be processed to obtain a significant amount of rare earth elements from carbonatites, leading to reduced production costs.

In contrast, other deposit types, such as ion-adsorption clays and monazite sands, may require more extensive and complex extraction methods, increasing overall production expenses. Additionally, some deposits may be located in remote or challenging terrains, which can add logistical and transportation costs to the mining operation.

Commercial Successes of Carbonatite-Based REE Projects

Carbonatite deposits have demonstrated their commercial viability through successful rare earth element mining projects worldwide. The Mountain Pass Mine in California and the Bayan Obo deposit in Inner Mongolia are notable examples of carbonatite-based REE projects that have achieved significant commercial success. These deposits have supplied substantial amounts of rare earth elements to meet global demand, contributing to various industries and technologies.

The commercial success of these carbonatite-based projects underscores the economic advantages and competitiveness of carbonatite deposits as a dominant source of rare earth elements.

Market Impact and Competitive Advantages of Carbonatites

The presence of carbonatite deposits in the rare earth element market has had a notable impact on the global supply chain. As these deposits offer high concentrations of REEs and prove economically viable, they help diversify the sources of rare earth elements, reducing dependence on a single supplier.

Carbonatites’ competitive advantages lie in their potential to offer stable and sustainable rare earth element supply. The development and utilization of these deposits can help mitigate geopolitical risks and create a more balanced and resilient rare earth element market.

Moreover, carbonatite-based REE projects can play a significant role in reducing market volatility and ensuring a steady supply of critical elements, supporting industries’ growth and technological advancements.

Overall, the comparative economic analysis highlights the superiority of carbonatite deposits as the most dominant and best source for rare earth elements. Their cost-effectiveness, commercial successes, and market impact position them as essential players in meeting the increasing global demand for these crucial resources. By leveraging carbonatite deposits responsibly and sustainably, we can secure the supply of rare earth elements and drive the development of innovative technologies essential for a sustainable future.


Carbonatite deposits have emerged as a cornerstone in the quest for meeting the growing demand for rare earth elements (REEs). Their unique geological characteristics, exceptional concentrations of REEs, and relatively straightforward extraction methods position them as the best and most dominant source for these critical elements.

Through the exploration of carbonatite deposits, we gain access to a treasure trove of rare earth elements that are pivotal in advancing modern technologies across industries. From clean energy technologies to electronics, telecommunications, and healthcare innovations, REEs derived from carbonatites play a vital role in driving progress and sustainability.

The case studies of notable carbonatite deposits, such as the Mountain Pass Mine in the USA, Bayan Obo in China, and Songwe Hill in Malawi, demonstrate the commercial success and significance of these deposits in contributing to the global REE supply.

Moreover, carbonatite deposits offer not only economic advantages but also the potential to reduce geopolitical risks in the rare earth element market. Diversifying the sources of REEs through carbonatite-based projects can enhance the stability and resilience of the global supply chain.

To harness the full potential of carbonatite deposits responsibly, the industry must embrace sustainable mining practices and promote the recycling and reusing of rare earth elements. By doing so, we can minimize environmental impacts, support local communities, and pave the way for a greener and more sustainable future.

Carbonatite deposits stand as a beacon of hope in meeting the increasing demand for rare earth elements while fostering innovation and progress in a world striving for sustainability. By embracing these unique geological formations, we can secure the supply of rare earth elements, enrich our technological landscape, and contribute to a more sustainable and prosperous global society.


  1. United States Geological Survey (USGS). (2020). Rare Earths. Retrieved from
  2. European Commission. (2014). Critical raw materials for the EU – Report of the Ad-hoc Working Group on defining critical raw materials. Retrieved from
  3. Castor, S. B., & Hedrick, J. B. (2006). Rare earth elements. In USGS Minerals Yearbook, 2006. U.S. Geological Survey.
  4. Verplanck, P. L., Van Gosen, B. S., Seal II, R. R., & Long, K. R. (2018). Rare earth element deposits in the United States. U.S. Geological Survey.
  5. Wall, F. (2013). Rare earth elements. In K. H. J. Heinrich (Ed.), Mineral Deposits of Finland (pp. 1075-1118). Elsevier.
  6. Life Cycle Associates. (2012). Rare Earth Elements: A Review of Production, Processing, Recycling, and Associated Environmental Issues. Retrieved from
  7. Hein, J. R., Petersen, S., Mizell, K., Essene, E. J., & Garrison, M. (2019). Marine phosphorites as potential resources for heavy rare earth elements, titanium, and nickel. Ore Geology Reviews, 107, 938-955.
  8. Chen, Y., Graedel, T. E., & Tan, H. (2015). A review of the recycling of rare earth metals in the United States. Environmental Science & Technology, 49(2), 8
  9. Wall, F., & Mariano, A. N. (1996). Rare earth minerals in carbonatites: a discussion centered on the Kangankunde Carbonatite, Malawi. In Evolution of African granitoids (pp. 181-196). Springer, Dordrecht.
  10. Verwoerd, W. J. (2002). Carbonatites: genesis and evolution. Journal of African Earth Sciences, 34(1), 3-75.
  11. Goodenough, K. M., Wall, F., & Merriman, D. (2008). The rare earth elements: demand, global resources, and challenges for resourcing future generations. Natural Resources Research, 17(2), 127-140.
  12. International Energy Agency (IEA). (2020). Sustainable Development Scenario. Retrieved from
  13. World Health Organization (WHO). (2020). Gadolinium-based contrast agents. Retrieved from
  14. Gombola, C. (2017). Rare Earth Elements in National Defense: Background, Oversight Issues, and Options for Congress. Congressional Research Service.
  15. United States Geological Survey (USGS). (2021). Rare Earth Elements: Trends, Applications, Mining, and Geopolitics. Retrieved from
  16. Holtstam, D., & Mansfeld, J. (2001). Carbonatites and associated nepheline syenites of Sweden. Geologica Acta, 1(1), 23-42.
  17. Schilling, J., Berger, J., Kreuzer, H., & Norton, P. (1980). The Mountain Pass rare-earth carbonatite and associated ultrapotassic rocks, California, a new look. Economic Geology, 75(3), 366-387.
  18. Chen, Z. (2014). Mining, refining, and recycling of rare earths. In The Rare Earth Elements (pp. 227-250). Springer, Dordrecht.
  19. Garcia, A., Wall, F., & Lusty, P. (2015). Technology metals in the future of manufacturing. International Journal of Minerals, Metallurgy, and Materials, 22(9), 945-954.
  20. European Commission. (2020). Study on the review of the list of critical raw materials—Final report. Retrieved from
  21. Wang, X., Han, Y., Yuan, Z., & Bai, G. (2011). Rare earth element deposits in China.

Disclaimer: This article, along with any associated content, contains forward-looking information or forward-looking statements (collectively “forward-looking information”) within the meaning of applicable securities laws. Such forward-looking information is typically identified by terms such as: “believe”, “expect”, “anticipate”, “intend”, “estimate”, “potentially”, and similar expressions, or statements that events or conditions “may”, “will”, “could”, or “should” occur. Both Zimtu and Commerce Resources caution readers and investors that any forward-looking information provided herein is not a guarantee of future results or performance, and that actual results may differ materially from those in the forward-looking information due to various factors. Readers are referred to Commerce Resources public filings for a more comprehensive discussion of potential risk factors and their potential effects, which may be accessed through its profile on appropriate regulatory websites.

Please read the full disclaimer within the entirety of this content, as fundamental risks and conflicts of interest exist. The author of this article has been compensated by Zimtu for the preparation, publication, and distribution of this content. Zimtu has been paid by Commerce Resources for various services, including the distribution of this article. Note that Zimtu likely holds a financial interest related to Commerce Resources and will profit from volume and price appreciation. Readers and investors are advised to conduct their own independent research and due diligence before making any investment decisions related to the content of this article.